Good pickled beef tongue is one of the cheapest genuinely special things you can make, and almost all of the work is waiting. Five days in a spiced brine, three hours at a bare simmer, and you have two pounds of dense, faintly sweet, faintly juniper-scented meat that slices like ham and costs a fraction of it.
The two things that go wrong are both about salt. Old recipes call for a brine so strong that the salt will not stay dissolved when it cools, and then tell you to rinse the meat for a moment before cooking it. Do both and the tongue is inedible. This version uses a brine at the strength charcuterie books actually use for immersion curing, and then soaks the salt back out properly before it ever reaches the pot.
- A brine at 10 percent salt, which cures properly and stays dissolved when it cools
- A real soaking step, so the finished meat is seasoned rather than salty
- Juniper, clove and brown sugar give it the flavor of good deli meat
- One of the cheapest cuts on the counter turns into something people ask about
- It keeps a week refrigerated and slices better cold than warm
- Curing salt is optional and the recipe tells you exactly what it changes
Almost everything here is unattended, but the order and the timings are not negotiable.
- What Pickled Beef Tongue Actually Is
- Getting the Brine Strength Right
- Ingredient Notes
- How To Make Pickled Beef Tongue
- Why Curing Salt Makes It Pink
- Simmering and Peeling Pickled Beef Tongue
- Make It Ahead
- Storing Pickled Beef Tongue
- Variations and Substitutions
- What to Serve with Pickled Beef Tongue
- Pickled Beef Tongue FAQ
What Pickled Beef Tongue Actually Is
Despite the name, nothing in pickled beef tongue is pickled in the vinegar sense. There is no vinegar anywhere in the recipe.
It is a brine cure, the same process as corned beef. The tongue sits submerged in salted, spiced water for several days. Salt moves into the meat, water moves out, and the flavor of the spices travels in with the brine. “Pickled” here is the older English sense of the word, meaning preserved in brine.
Then it is boiled, gently. Tongue is a hard-working muscle wrapped in a thick rubbery skin, so it needs hours at a low temperature to turn tender. The skin peels off afterward and is discarded.
What you end up with is a dense, close-grained meat somewhere between corned beef and a very good ham, with almost no chew and none of the offal flavor people brace themselves for. Most first-timers guess roast beef.
The cut is cheap because of the name. That is the whole reason pickled beef tongue is worth your attention.
Save this recipe
Enter your email and I’ll send this recipe straight to your inbox.
Getting the Brine Strength Right
This is the part that most old pickled beef tongue recipes get badly wrong, and it is worth explaining rather than just fixing.
The version this post used to carry called for 27 ounces of salt in 3 quarts of water. That is about 27 percent salt by weight. Table salt saturates water at roughly 26 percent, and less than that at refrigerator temperature, so a brine that strong cannot stay dissolved. It goes into the pan clear and hot and comes out with salt sitting on the bottom.
Ten ounces in the same 3 quarts is about 10 percent, which is the range charcuterie books use for immersion curing and which stays in solution cold. Five days at that strength cures a 3-pound tongue right through.
Weigh the salt, do not measure it by volume. Coarse crystals vary enormously. The same cup can hold anywhere from 5 to 10 ounces depending on the brand.
Cool the brine completely before the meat goes in. Warm brine on raw meat is the one genuine food safety mistake available here.
Keep it submerged and keep it below 40F for the whole cure.
Ingredient Notes
Pickled beef tongue takes nine things in the brine and six in the pot, and most of them are already in your cupboard. Exact amounts are in the recipe card below.
- Beef tongue: about 3 pounds, fresh rather than frozen if you can. Ask a butcher; supermarkets rarely display it but often have it. Veal tongue is smaller, milder and cures in three days.
- Coarse sea salt: 10 ounces, weighed. Any pure salt works. Avoid iodized table salt, which can leave a faint metallic edge over five days.
- Dark brown sugar: 4 ounces. It is not there to sweeten so much as to soften the salt and help the color.
- Juniper berries: two teaspoons, crushed lightly. This is the flavor people cannot place and remember afterward.
- Cloves, bay and peppercorns: the standard brine spices. Whole, never ground.
- Pink curing salt: optional. It makes the difference between rosy pink meat and gray-brown meat, and it is discussed in its own section below.
- Aromatic vegetables: onion, carrot, celery and a head of garlic for the cooking water, plus a bouquet garni. None of this ends up on the plate.
Pickled beef tongue needs a nonreactive container that holds the tongue and 3 quarts of liquid, and a plate or a bag of water to weigh it down.
How To Make Pickled Beef Tongue
Five stages spread over six days, of which about three hours are actual work.
- First, heat the water with the salt, sugar and spices until everything has dissolved, then take it off the heat and let it cool completely to refrigerator temperature. This takes several hours, so do it the day before.
- Next, put the tongue in a nonreactive container, pour the cold brine over it, weigh it down so it stays under the surface and refrigerate 5 days, turning it once a day.
- Then lift it out, discard the brine and soak the tongue in fresh cold water for 4 hours with three changes of water, or overnight in the refrigerator. This step is what makes it edible.
- After that, cover it with fresh water in a large pot, add the vegetables and bouquet garni, bring it barely to a boil and drop straight to the gentlest simmer for 2 1/2 to 3 1/2 hours, until a skewer meets no resistance at all.
- Finally, lift it out and peel the skin off while it is still hot, trim the gristle from the root end, and either slice it warm or press it and chill it overnight for cleaner slices.
Why Curing Salt Makes It Pink
Every photograph of deli tongue shows pink meat, and pickled beef tongue made at home does not come out that way by default. Plain salt will not give you that, and it is worth knowing why before you decide.
The pink comes from nitrite. Pink curing salt, sold as Prague powder number 1 or Insta Cure number 1, is ordinary salt dyed pink and mixed with about six percent sodium nitrite. It reacts with the meat pigment and fixes it as a stable pink, and it also produces the particular tangy flavor everyone recognizes as cured.
Without it the meat is gray-brown. Exactly like a boiled beef joint. It tastes very good and it looks like nothing you have seen in a deli.
It is not required for safety here. A brine cure held below 40F in the refrigerator does not need nitrite the way a room-temperature or smoked cure does. This is a color and flavor decision.
If you use it, follow the package. Most brands specify 1 ounce per gallon of brine for immersion curing, which is about 3/4 ounce for the 3 quarts here. Do not eyeball it and do not increase it.
Simmering and Peeling Pickled Beef Tongue
The cooking is where the texture of pickled beef tongue is decided, and there is one rule that matters more than the clock.
Never let it boil. A rolling boil squeezes a muscle this dense into something stringy and dry. You want the barest movement on the surface, around 180F to 190F, for the whole time.
Test with a skewer, not a timer. Three pounds usually takes about three hours, but tongues vary. It is ready when a thin skewer pushes into the thickest part and out again with no resistance whatsoever.
Peel it the moment you can handle it. Slit the skin along the underside with a small knife and it will pull away in large pieces. Wear a clean glove if it is too hot for bare hands.
Trim the root end. There is gristle, fat and sometimes small bones at the thick end. Cut them away and discard them.
Slice across the grain, thin. Thick slices of pickled beef tongue chew; thin ones melt.
Make It Ahead
Pickled beef tongue is almost entirely make-ahead by nature, and it improves for it.
The brine can be made a week early and kept refrigerated, which removes the several hours it needs to cool from the day you start.
The cure is five days and is not a task, only a wait. Turn it once a day so it cures evenly.
Cook it a day before you serve it. Peel it hot, wrap it tightly in plastic, press it under a weight in the refrigerator overnight and it slices far more cleanly cold than warm.
It keeps a week once cooked, so a Sunday batch of pickled beef tongue feeds you sandwiches into the following weekend.
What you cannot rush is the soak. Four hours with three changes of water is the minimum, and if you skip it because you are behind schedule, the meat will be too salty to serve and there is no way back.
Storing Pickled Beef Tongue
- Cooked and whole, refrigerated: pickled beef tongue keeps 1 week wrapped tightly, and slicing it as you go keeps it moist.
- Sliced: 4 days, covered with a little of the strained cooking liquid so the edges do not dry out.
- Frozen: 3 months, cooked and whole. Slice it after it thaws, never before.
- In the brine: do not exceed 7 days of curing. Past that the outer inch turns hard and unpleasantly salty.
- Throw the used brine away. It has held raw meat for five days and is not reusable.
Variations and Substitutions
In pickled beef tongue the salt strength and the soak are fixed. The spices and the finish are yours.
- Veal tongue: smaller and more delicate. Cure it 3 days and simmer about 2 hours.
- Pastrami style: after the cure and soak, coat it in cracked pepper and coriander and smoke it low before simmering.
- Add allspice and mustard seed to the brine for something closer to a British spiced beef.
- Serve it hot with boiled potatoes and cabbage, in which case it behaves exactly like the beef in my unstuffed cabbage rolls.
- Save the cooking liquid. Strained, it is an excellent base for a barley soup or the stock in my old fashioned beef stew.
- Skip the sugar for a plainer, saltier cure closer to traditional salt beef.
What to Serve with Pickled Beef Tongue
Pickled beef tongue is rich, dense and salty, so everything around it should be sharp.
- Grated horseradish or a sharp mustard, which is the traditional pairing and still the best one.
- Cucumber pickles or a jar of my pickled vegetables, for acidity and crunch against the fat.
- Rye bread and butter, cold meat piled thick, which is what most of it will end up as.
- Boiled new potatoes and parsley, if you are serving it hot as a main course.
- On a board with sausage and goat cheese meatball sandwiches when you are feeding a crowd cold cuts.
Here is what readers ask most often.
Pickled Beef Tongue FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
Is this the same thing as tongue pickles?
No, and the names are genuinely confusing. Tongue pickles are a sweet cucumber pickle from Vermont and New England, usually made with maple syrup and cinnamon, named for the long tongue-shaped slices. This recipe is pickled beef tongue, meaning a whole beef tongue cured in brine, which is an entirely different thing that happens to share a word.
How long should the tongue stay in the brine?
Five days for a tongue of about 3 pounds, turning it once a day so it cures evenly, and never longer than seven. A veal tongue needs three. The cure has to reach the middle, so a bigger tongue needs the full time, but past a week the outside becomes hard and oversalted and no amount of soaking rescues it.
Do I really have to soak it after curing?
Yes. This is the step that decides whether the finished meat is seasoned or ruined, and it is the one most often left out. Four hours in cold water with three complete changes is the minimum, and overnight in the refrigerator is better. Skipping it leaves a tongue you cannot eat and cannot fix afterward.
More Questions About Curing and Cooking
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know when it is done?
By feel, not by the clock. Push a thin skewer into the thickest part of the tongue; when it goes in and comes out with no resistance at all, it is ready. That is usually close to three hours for 3 pounds, but tongues differ enough that timing alone will let you down. Undercooked tongue is rubbery, and the only cure is more time.
Why is my tongue gray instead of pink?
Because there was no curing salt in the brine. Nitrite is what fixes the pink color in cured meat, and plain salt cannot do it. Gray-brown is the correct and expected result of an uncured brine, and it tastes just as good. If you want the deli look, add pink curing salt at the rate the package specifies for immersion curing.
Can I use the leftover cooking liquid?
The cooking liquid, yes, and it is excellent. Strain it, chill it and lift the fat off, and you have a well-seasoned beef stock for soup. Taste it before you use it, because it may be salty enough that it needs diluting. The curing brine, however, goes down the drain.
Fix the salt and add the soak and pickled beef tongue turns from a heritage recipe people are afraid of into a cheap, reliable week of very good sandwiches. For something sharp to eat alongside it, make a jar of my pickled vegetables while the tongue is curing.
Pickled Beef Tongue with Juniper and Brown Sugar
Save this recipe
Enter your email and I’ll send this recipe straight to your inbox.
Ingredients
The Curing Brine
- 3 quarts water
- 10 ounces coarse sea salt about 285 grams, weighed rather than measured by volume
- 4 ounces dark brown sugar about 1/2 cup, packed
- 2 teaspoons black peppercorns whole
- 2 teaspoons juniper berries lightly crushed
- 4 whole cloves
- 3 bay leaves dried
- 6 cloves garlic smashed
- 3/4 ounce pink curing salt optional, for color only; follow the package directions for immersion curing
The Tongue and the Pot
- 3 pounds beef tongue one whole fresh tongue
- 1 large onion peeled and halved
- 1 large carrot chopped
- 1 stalk celery chopped
- 1 head garlic halved crosswise
- 1 bouquet garni a few parsley stalks, 2 thyme sprigs and a bay leaf tied together
- 1 teaspoon black peppercorns for the cooking water
Equipment
- Large saucepan
- Large container or crock for brining
- Slotted spoon
- Cutting board
- Sharp knife
Instructions
Make and Cool the Brine
- Put the water, sea salt, brown sugar, peppercorns, juniper, cloves, bay leaves and smashed garlic into a large pan. Warm over low heat, stirring, only until the salt and sugar have completely dissolved. Do not boil it hard.
- Take it off the heat and cool it all the way to refrigerator temperature, several hours or overnight. If you are using pink curing salt, stir it in once the brine is cold, at the rate the package gives for immersion curing. The brine must be cold before it meets the meat.
Cure the Tongue
- Rinse the tongue and put it into a nonreactive container that holds it snugly. Pour the cold brine over it and weigh it down with a plate or a sealed bag of water so that no part of it sits above the surface.
- Refrigerate 5 days at or below 40F, turning the tongue once a day. Do not go beyond 7 days: the outer inch turns hard and oversalted and soaking will not recover it.
Soak Out the Salt
- Lift the tongue out and pour the brine away. Put the tongue in a bowl of fresh cold water and soak it for 4 hours, changing the water completely three times, or leave it overnight in the refrigerator. This step is what makes the difference between seasoned meat and meat nobody can eat.
Simmer Until Tender
- Put the tongue in a large pot with the onion, carrot, celery, halved head of garlic, bouquet garni and the teaspoon of peppercorns, and cover it with fresh cold water by two inches.
- Bring it barely to a boil, then drop the heat immediately so the surface only shivers, around 180F to 190F, and hold it there for 2 1/2 to 3 1/2 hours. Never let it boil properly or the meat turns stringy. It is done when a thin skewer slides into the thickest part and out again with no resistance at all.
Peel and Slice
- Lift the tongue onto a board and peel it while it is still hot. Slit the skin along the underside with a small knife and pull it away in sheets. Once it cools the skin tightens and grips, and you will lose meat prising it off.
- Trim the gristle, fat and any small bones from the thick root end and discard them. Slice thin across the grain and serve warm, or wrap it tightly, press it under a weight in the refrigerator overnight and slice it cold for cleaner slices and sandwiches.