Easy Cannoli Pie Recipe

Cannoli pie is what happens when you want cannoli on a Tuesday and have no intention of frying shells, rolling them around metal tubes, or piping filling into thirty of them one at a time. It is the same ricotta filling, the same mini chocolate chips, the same cinnamon and vanilla, spread into a crumb crust and chilled until it slices clean.

The trade is honest. You give up the shatter of a fried shell and you get a dessert that feeds eight, takes twenty minutes of actual work, and can be made a full day before anyone arrives. For a holiday table where the oven is already booked solid, that is not a compromise. That is the point.

What Is Cannoli Pie?

A cannoli is a fried pastry tube filled with sweetened ricotta. Cannoli pie takes the filling, keeps it exactly as it should be, and gives it a pressed crumb crust instead of a shell. Everything that makes the original worth eating survives the translation: the slight graininess of real ricotta, the cinnamon, the bite of mini chocolate chips, the powdered sugar on top.

What you lose is the crunch, and there is no honest way around that. What you gain is scale and timing. One pan, eight slices, and it improves overnight instead of going soft within the hour the way a filled shell does. Anyone who has filled cannoli two hours before a party and watched them turn soggy will understand immediately why this version exists.

The crust here is baked for eight minutes and the filling is not baked at all. That matters for texture. Ricotta that goes into an oven tightens and can weep; ricotta that is whipped cold and chilled stays creamy.

It is also worth saying that cannoli pie is not a cheesecake, whatever the pan suggests. There are no eggs, nothing bakes, and nothing sets by coagulation. It firms up because cold fat firms up, which is why the chill time is the recipe rather than an afterthought to it.

Save this recipe

Enter your email and I’ll send this recipe straight to your inbox.

Email address

Email me this recipe

Website

Ingredient Notes

• Whole milk ricotta. Not part-skim, and it has to be drained. This is the single decision that determines whether your pie slices or slumps, and there is more on it below.
• Mascarpone. One cup, at room temperature. Cold mascarpone seizes into lumps that never fully beat out. Take it out of the fridge thirty minutes ahead. It is what turns a grainy ricotta filling silky, and cream cheese is not the same swap, though it will work in a pinch.
• Powdered sugar. Three-quarters of a cup, and it must be powdered rather than granulated. Granulated sugar will not dissolve in a cold filling, and you will feel every grain.
• Mini chocolate chips. Half a cup folded in, more on top. Minis specifically. Regular chips are too heavy for a soft filling and sink to the bottom while it chills.
• Cinnamon. Half a teaspoon. It sounds like a small amount, and it is the thing that makes people say this tastes like a cannoli rather than like a cheesecake. Buy it fresh; ground cinnamon that has sat in a cupboard for three years contributes almost nothing.
• Vanilla extract. One teaspoon, and real extract rather than imitation. In a filling this plain there is nowhere for a synthetic vanilla note to hide.
• Graham cracker crumbs. A cup and a half with six tablespoons of melted butter. Crushed shortbread or vanilla wafers work too, and if you want to lean Italian, crushed amaretti are excellent.

Ricotta Is the Whole Game

Supermarket ricotta carries a surprising amount of liquid, and every ounce of it ends up in your filling if you let it. Undrained ricotta is why most first attempts refuse to hold a slice.

Line a sieve with a double layer of cheesecloth or a couple of coffee filters, set it over a bowl, tip the ricotta in, and leave it in the fridge for at least two hours. Overnight is better. You will pour off a startling amount of whey. That whey is not waste, incidentally: it is the same liquid ricotta itself is traditionally made from, as Penn State Extension explains in its guide to home cheesemaking.

If you are short on time, press the ricotta between layers of paper towel with a plate and a can on top for thirty minutes. It is not as thorough, but it removes enough to save the texture.

Cannoli Pie vs Cannoli Dip

These two get confused constantly and they are not the same thing. Cannoli dip is the filling, loosened deliberately, served in a bowl with broken shell pieces or waffle cone shards for scooping. It is a party food and it is meant to be soft.

Cannoli pie is the filling set firm enough to hold a wedge, in a crust that does the job the shell used to do. The ingredient list overlaps almost completely; the difference is entirely in the draining and the chilling. Skip either one, and what you have made is dip in a pie pan, which tastes exactly as good and will not slice.

If a slice is what you want, the two non-negotiable steps are draining the ricotta properly and giving it the full four hours in the fridge. Everything else in this recipe is flexible.

How To Make Cannoli Pie

First, make the crust. Heat the oven to 350 degrees. Stir the crumbs, granulated sugar, melted butter and a pinch of salt together until the mixture looks like damp sand and holds when you squeeze it.

Next, press and bake. Push it firmly into the bottom and up the sides of a nine-inch pie pan, using a flat measuring cup to compact it. Bake eight to ten minutes, until it smells toasty and the edges have gone a shade darker. Then let it cool completely. A warm crust will melt the filling.

Then beat the filling. Put the drained ricotta, the mascarpone and the powdered sugar in a bowl and beat on medium for about two minutes, until it is smooth and no longer looks curdled. Add the vanilla, cinnamon and salt and beat on low just until combined.

After that, fold and fill. Add the mini chocolate chips with a spatula rather than the mixer, folding gently so you do not knock the air out. Spoon it into the cooled crust and smooth the top.

Finally, chill. Cover and refrigerate at least four hours. Overnight is genuinely better; the filling firms up and the cinnamon settles into everything. Top with more chips, a dusting of powdered sugar, whipped cream and chopped pistachios just before it goes to the table, never before it chills.

How To Tell When It Is Set

Press the center gently with a fingertip. It should feel firm and spring back rather than dent. A knife slid into the middle and pulled straight out should come away clean, with the cut edge holding its shape instead of closing behind the blade. If it closes, it needs another hour and probably better draining next time.

Make It Ahead

This is a make-ahead dessert by design. Assemble it a full day early, cover it tightly, and leave the toppings off. Whipped cream weeps if it sits, and powdered sugar dissolves into the surface within a couple of hours and disappears.

You can go further and split the work across two days: drain the ricotta and bake the crust on day one, fill and chill on day two. The baked crust keeps at room temperature overnight under foil without going soft.

Storing Cannoli Pie

Covered in the fridge, cannoli pie keeps three to four days and slices better on day two than it does on day one. Press plastic wrap against the cut edges rather than only over the top, or the exposed filling dries and forms a skin.

Freezing is possible but it is not the version I would serve to guests. Ricotta goes slightly grainy after thawing. If you want to try it, freeze the whole pie unwrapped for an hour to firm the surface, then double wrap and freeze up to a month, and thaw overnight in the fridge rather than on the counter.

The crust softens with time no matter what you do, which is another argument for eating it inside three days. It is rarely a problem in practice.

Variations and Substitutions

Orange zest. A teaspoon of finely grated zest in the filling is traditional in Sicily and it lifts the whole thing. Lemon zest works too and reads brighter.

Pistachio crust. Swap a third of the crumbs for finely ground pistachios. It is the most Italian version of this pie and the color is beautiful.

Chocolate crust. Chocolate graham crumbs or crushed chocolate wafers, same quantities. Skip the chips on top and shave a bar over it instead.

Cream cheese. If mascarpone is not available, use full-fat cream cheese at room temperature. It is tangier and firmer, so add two tablespoons of heavy cream to loosen it.

No-bake crust. Press the crumb mixture in and chill it for an hour instead of baking. It is more fragile, and it makes the recipe genuinely no-bake from end to end.

Individual portions. Press the crust into a muffin tin lined with paper cases, bake five minutes rather than eight, and pipe the filling in once they are cool. You get twelve small ones that travel to a potluck far better than a whole pie does, and the ratio of crust to filling improves.

Candied peel. A tablespoon of finely chopped candied orange peel folded in with the chips is how a lot of Sicilian bakeries finish their filling. It is a small addition that makes the whole thing taste less American.

What to Serve with Cannoli Pie

Espresso. That is the whole answer, and it is the right one. The bitterness cuts a sweet, rich filling better than anything else on the table, and a small cup alongside a small slice is how this would be served in Palermo.

Beyond that, a bowl of berries on the side stops it feeling heavy after a big meal, and a glass of vin santo or marsala turns it into a proper end to a dinner. Sliced strawberries are the pairing I keep coming back to, because the acidity does the same job the espresso does.

Portion size is worth thinking about. This is rich, and a nine-inch pan cut into eight is generous. Cut into ten or twelve for a table that has already eaten a full Italian meal, and nobody will feel shortchanged.

If you are building a dessert table rather than serving one thing, it sits well next to an Italian cream sheet cake because they share a family resemblance without repeating each other.

Cannoli Pie FAQ

More Questions About No-Bake Italian Desserts

If this is the kind of dessert you want in your rotation, the same make-it-yesterday logic drives cherry cheesecake bars and an orange creamsicle no-bake cheesecake, both of which also get better sitting in the fridge overnight.