Pimento Cheese, Paula Deen Style

Pimento cheese is the one Southern spread that people are genuinely opinionated about. Everyone’s grandmother made it slightly differently, everyone insists their version is the correct one, and almost nobody thinks the plastic tub from the supermarket counts. Paula Deen’s version is the one I keep coming back to, because it leans on cream cheese for body and it never breaks or weeps the way a mayonnaise-only spread can.

It takes fifteen minutes of actual work and an hour in the fridge, and it makes enough for a party platter or a week of sandwiches. The only thing that separates a good bowl from a great one is the cheese you start with, which is a longer conversation than it sounds.

What Is Pimento Cheese?

At its simplest, pimento cheese is grated cheese bound with mayonnaise and studded with jarred pimento peppers. It is sometimes called the pate of the South, usually by people who are half joking, and it turns up at church suppers, tailgates, Masters weekend and in the middle of a white bread sandwich with the crusts cut off.

Pimentos themselves are sweet red peppers, not hot ones. They are heart-shaped, thin-walled and mild, and they are sold jarred and diced precisely because almost nobody roasts their own. That sweetness is the point. It offsets a sharp cheddar without adding heat.

The Paula Deen version adds two things to the standard formula: cream cheese and a house seasoning of garlic powder, salt and black pepper. The cream cheese is the structural decision. It emulsifies the spread so it stays smooth at room temperature, which matters when the bowl sits out for three hours at a party.

Save this recipe

Enter your email and I’ll send this recipe straight to your inbox.

Email address

Email me this recipe

Website

A Northern Invention That Went South

The odd part of the story is that this did not start as a Southern food at all. It came out of the turn of the century, when factory-made cream cheese and canned Spanish peppers both became cheap and widely available at roughly the same moment, and someone thought to put them together. The early recipes were printed in Northern magazines and sold as a fashionable sandwich filling.

What made it Southern was agriculture. Georgia farmers began growing the peppers commercially, canneries opened to process them, and within a generation the jarred product was in every grocery store between Virginia and Texas. A cheap, shelf-stable pepper met a region that already ate a great deal of cheddar, and the spread stopped being a novelty and became a staple.

That history explains the variation. There was never a single authoritative recipe handed down, only a formula loose enough that every family adjusted it. Some households swear by a grating of onion, some by pickle juice, some by a spoonful of sugar that they will deny under questioning. All of them are defensible, which is why the argument never ends.

Ingredient Notes

• Cream cheese. Eight ounces, full fat, genuinely soft. Take it out of the fridge half an hour ahead. Cold cream cheese leaves lumps that no amount of beating will smooth out later, once the grated cheese is in the way.
• Mayonnaise. Half a cup, full fat. Duke’s is the Southern default because it has no added sugar, but any real mayonnaise works. Salad dressing style spreads are sweeter and will change the balance.
• Sharp cheddar. One cup grated, from a block. Sharp rather than mild, because everything else in the bowl is soft and rich and something has to push back.
• Monterey Jack. One cup grated. It melts into the spread and keeps the texture creamy rather than crumbly. Colby or a mild white cheddar will do the same job.
• Diced pimentos. One four-ounce jar, drained well. Really drained, over the sink, pressed with the back of a spoon. The liquid in that jar is the main reason a batch turns watery overnight.
• Sweet onion. Two tablespoons, grated on a microplane rather than chopped. Grating releases juice and disperses the flavor evenly, where chopped onion reads as raw chunks.
• House seasoning. One teaspoon of equal parts garlic powder, salt and black pepper. It is the Paula Deen signature and it is worth mixing a jar of it, because it goes on everything.
• Salt and black pepper. To taste, at the end. The cheeses bring a lot of salt with them, so season last rather than first.

Grate the Cheese Yourself

This is the single change that makes the biggest difference, and it is the one most people skip. Pre-shredded cheese is coated with potato starch or cellulose to stop it clumping in the bag. That coating does not dissolve, and in a cold spread it reads as a faint chalkiness on the tongue.

A block of cheddar and four minutes with a box grater fixes it. The shreds are also longer and less uniform, which gives the finished bowl a better texture than the neat little matchsticks from a bag.

It helps to know what you are working with: cheddar and Monterey Jack are both firm cheeses made by cutting and pressing the curd, as U.S. Dairy sets out in its explanation of how cheese is made. Firm cheeses grate cleanly straight from the fridge. Let them warm up and they smear.

How To Make Pimento Cheese

First, beat the cream cheese alone. Put the softened block in a bowl and beat it with a hand mixer for a minute until it is smooth and fluffy, scraping the sides once. Doing this first is the whole trick, because lumps are impossible to remove later.

Next, add the mayonnaise and the house seasoning. Beat again until the mixture is uniform and looks like a thick frosting. If it seems stiff, add another spoonful of mayonnaise.

Then fold in everything else. Switch to a spatula and fold in the drained pimentos, the grated onion, the Monterey Jack and the sharp cheddar. Stop as soon as it is evenly distributed. Beating at this stage shreds the cheese and turns a chunky spread into a paste.

After that, taste and season. Add salt and black pepper a pinch at a time. It will taste slightly under-seasoned when it is warm from the mixer and correct once it is cold, so go lightly.

Finally, chill. Cover the bowl and refrigerate for at least an hour before serving, and overnight if you have the time.

Why It Has to Chill

Fresh from the bowl, pimento cheese tastes like its separate parts: onion here, cheddar there, a background of mayonnaise. An hour in the fridge lets the cream cheese set around the shreds and the garlic and onion spread through everything. Overnight is better still, which is why this belongs on the day-before list rather than the day-of one.

How To Tell When Pimento Cheese Is Ready

Scoop a spoonful and turn it sideways. It should hold its shape and mound rather than slump back into the bowl, and a cracker pushed into it should come out loaded rather than smeared. If it slides, it either needs another hour in the fridge or the pimentos were not drained hard enough.

The taste test is a separate matter. Cold food tastes less salty than warm food, so judge the seasoning straight from the fridge rather than off the mixer beater. If it needs more, add it a pinch at a time and stir; you cannot take it back out.

Make It Ahead

This is a day-before recipe by design. Make it a full twenty-four hours in advance, cover it tightly, and take it out of the fridge twenty minutes before it goes on the table so it softens enough to spread.

For a party, I make a double batch two days out. The flavor keeps improving through day two and it frees the morning of the event entirely. Hold back a tablespoon of the pimentos and scatter them on top just before serving, which stops the surface looking flat.

What does not work is freezing. Mayonnaise splits on thawing and the texture never recovers, so make what you will eat inside a week.

Storing Pimento Cheese

An airtight container in the fridge keeps it for a week. Press a sheet of plastic wrap onto the surface if you want to be thorough, because the exposed top dries and darkens slightly after a few days.

If a little liquid gathers at the edges, pour it off and stir. That is normal with jarred pimentos and it is not a sign that anything has gone wrong.

Leave the bowl out for no more than two hours at a party. It is a dairy spread bound with mayonnaise, and it plays by the same rules as any other cold dip on a warm afternoon.

Variations and Substitutions

Add heat. A diced jalapeno, a spoonful of pickled jalapeno brine, or a quarter teaspoon of cayenne. This is the most common Southern variation and it does not fight the sweetness of the peppers.

Pickle juice. A tablespoon of dill pickle brine in place of some of the mayonnaise gives it a tang that a lot of old family recipes rely on.

Smoked cheddar. Swap half the sharp cheddar for smoked. It turns the whole bowl into something you would serve with barbecue rather than with crackers.

Greek yogurt. Replace half the mayonnaise with full-fat Greek yogurt for a lighter, tangier spread. It will be slightly looser, so chill it a little longer.

Worcestershire sauce. Half a teaspoon adds a savory depth that is hard to place and easy to miss once it is gone.

Chunky style. Grate half the cheddar on the large holes and hand-chop the rest into small cubes. It gives the spread real bite and it is closer to the way the older Carolina versions were made.

What to Serve with Pimento Cheese

Crackers are the default and a plain, salty, slightly buttery cracker is the right one. Celery sticks, sweet pepper strips and pretzel crisps all work, and a bowl of it on a cheese board next to a cranberry pecan cheese ball covers both the savory and the sweet ends of a party spread.

It is also a sandwich filling, and that is arguably its truest form: soft white bread, a thick layer, no lettuce, cut into triangles. Grilled is even better, because the cheddar melts and the cream cheese goes molten.

Beyond that, it belongs on a burger, stirred into grits, spooned over a baked potato, or melted onto a hot dog. If you are building a bigger appetizer table, a bowl of homemade Wingstop ranch gives people a second thing to dip into, and Outback mac and cheese carries the same cheddar note over to the main course.

Pimento Cheese FAQ

More Questions About Southern Cheese Spreads

Pimento cheese is the kind of recipe that rewards making it once and then never buying it again. If you want another cold, creamy thing that improves overnight, cherry cheesecake dip works the same way at the other end of the table.